Is PVA safe?

Is PVA safe?

Is PVA Safe for the Environment?

At ReShine Earth, we care deeply about the sustainability and environmental impact of our products. One topic that has recently garnered attention is the use of Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA) in various household items, including our laundry sheets. This post aims to provide a comprehensive overview of PVA, its environmental safety, and how it compares to other materials.

Understanding PVA

Polyvinyl Alcohol (PVA) is a water-soluble synthetic polymer. It is a colorless, odorless, non-toxic, and biodegradable material created through a series of chemical reactions starting from ethylene. PVA has been widely used for decades across various industries, including textiles, paper, pharmaceuticals, and cleaning products.

Common Uses of PVA

  1. Textile Industry: PVA is used as a warp sizing agent to strengthen yarns, reducing breakage during weaving.
  2. Packaging: Utilized for water-soluble films in single-use applications, contributing to eco-friendly packaging solutions.
  3. Paper Industry: Employed as a coating agent to enhance paper's grease and oil resistance.
  4. Pharmaceuticals and Food Packaging: Approved by the FDA for these uses due to its safety and biodegradability.
  5. Household Products: Found in dishwasher sheets and tablets, laundry sheets, and other cleaning products.
  6. Personal Care and Healthcare: Used in contact lens lubricants and children’s play slime, demonstrating its safety for direct human contact​ (lowcarbonbuildings.org)​​ (vove)​.

    Environmental Impact of PVA

    Biodegradability: PVA's biodegradability is one of its most significant eco-friendly attributes. Unlike many traditional plastics, PVA can be broken down by specific bacteria in suitable environmental conditions. Research indicates that PVA biodegrades by at least 60% within 28 days and nearly completely within 90 days​ (lowcarbonbuildings.org)​​ (vove)​.

    Water-Solubility: PVA’s ability to dissolve in water limits its potential to contribute to long-term environmental pollution. This property ensures that PVA does not accumulate as solid waste in the environment.

    Non-Toxicity: PVA is non-toxic, making it a preferred choice for products that come into contact with the human body and for applications where safety is paramount​ (lowcarbonbuildings.org)​​ (vove)​.

    Microplastics: PVA does not contribute to microplastic pollution. Its water solubility and biodegradability ensure that it dissolves and breaks down without forming harmful particles​ (lowcarbonbuildings.org)​​ (vove)​.

    Addressing Recent Concerns

    Recently, some concerns were raised about PVA's biodegradability in wastewater treatment plants. These concerns were primarily based on a study funded by Blueland, a company that does not use PVA in its competing products. The study suggested that PVA might not fully biodegrade in these settings. However, this study has been criticized for not focusing on the specific types of PVA used in products like laundry sheets and for not adequately considering the existing body of research that supports PVA's biodegradability​ (epa)​.

    Independent Reviews and Studies

    Several independent studies and expert reviews have reinforced PVA's safety and environmental benefits:

    • A review by DeMerlis and Schoneker concluded that PVA is safe for human consumption, highlighting its use in pharmaceutical products​ (epa)​.
    • Research published in "Tenside Surfactants Detergents" demonstrated that PVA films used in detergent capsules are readily biodegradable​ (epa)​.
    • Studies have shown that PVA does not form microplastics, as it completely dissolves in water and biodegrades through natural processes​ (lowcarbonbuildings.org)​​ (vove)​.

      Here is an analysis of each citation provided in the original document, with a focus on summarizing the key points and any critiques noted in the retrieved materials.

      1. DeMerlis CC, Schoneker DR. (2003)

        Summary: This review addresses the oral toxicity of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA). It evaluates various studies on the ingestion of PVA, indicating low toxicity in animal studies and supporting its safety for use in food packaging and pharmaceutical application. Critique: The document mentions that the study did not prove the claims against PVA since the researchers did not perform original tests but instead used data from other studies to create a hypothetical model, which led to inaccuracies​.

      2. Byrne, D. et al. (2021)

        Summary: This paper examines the biodegradability of PVA-based films used in liquid detergent capsules. It suggests that these films degrade effectively under specific conditions found in wastewater treatment plants. Critique: The retrieved document disputes the applicability of these findings, arguing that the specific microbes necessary for PVA degradation in these studies are not present in most wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) or natural environments. It also points out that the testing methods (OECD series) do not reflect real-world conditions​

      3. Salehpour S, et al. (2018)

        Summary: This study focuses on the biodegradation and ecotoxicological impact of cellulose nanocomposites in municipal solid waste composting. It explores how these materials break down and their effects on the environment. Critique: This citation was not directly critiqued in the retrieved documents, implying it may not have been a central point in the debate over PVA’s environmental impact.

      4. Chiellini, E. et al. (2003)

        Summary: This review article discusses the biodegradation of PVA-based materials, highlighting the conditions under which PVA can biodegrade and the environmental factors affecting this process. Critique: The document acknowledges biodegradation under specific conditions but questions the relevance of these conditions to real-world WWTPs, suggesting that the necessary microbial communities for PVA degradation are often absent​.

      5. Rolsky, C.; Kelkar, V. (2021)

        Summary: This paper investigates the degradation of PVA in US wastewater treatment plants and estimates nationwide emissions. It concludes that a significant portion of PVA is released into the environment due to insufficient degradation. Critique: The document strongly criticizes this study, claiming it did not follow EPA guidelines for scaling lab results to real-world scenarios. It also highlights mathematical errors and arbitrary assumptions, suggesting that the study's conclusions are fundamentally flawed​.

      6. Freedhoff, M. Letter to Paiji Yoo, S., Cohen, D. (April 21, 2023)

        Summary: This letter from the EPA responds to concerns raised about PVA, addressing its regulatory status and environmental safety. Critique: The document leverages this letter to reinforce the stance that the claims against PVA’s safety and biodegradability have been evaluated and rejected by the EPA, emphasizing the agency's expertise and regulatory authority​.

      7. Freedhoff, M. Pre-publication notice. (April 21, 2023)

        Summary: Similar to the letter, this notice outlines the EPA’s stance on PVA, detailing the scientific basis for its conclusions and regulatory decisions. Critique: The document uses this notice to further debunk claims against PVA, highlighting extensive scientific reviews and regulatory approvals confirming PVA’s safety and biodegradability in appropriate contexts                            Overall, studies emphasize discrepancies between laboratory studies and real-world conditions, particularly concerning the biodegradation of PVA. They also point out inaccuracies and methodological flaws in some studies that claim significant environmental risks associated with PVA, reinforcing the EPA’s findings that support PVA’s safety and biodegradability under specified conditions.

        Are there any studies done in any other part of the world related to this subject?

        Yes, several studies have been conducted worldwide regarding the environmental impact and biodegradability of PVA (polyvinyl alcohol). Here are some notable examples:

        1. Biodegradability in Japan: A study conducted in Japan assessed the biodegradability of PVA under various environmental conditions. The research found that certain strains of bacteria, such as Pseudomonas species, can effectively degrade PVA in both soil and water environments. This indicates that PVA can be broken down by microorganisms present in natural settings under suitable conditions​ (lowcarbonbuildings.org)​.
        2. Environmental Impact Assessment in the EU: The European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and the European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) have evaluated PVA for its environmental and human health impacts. These assessments confirmed that PVA is non-toxic and poses minimal risk when used in food packaging and medical applications. Its water-solubility and biodegradability make it a safer alternative to traditional plastics​ (fominsoap)​.
        3. Study in China on PVA’s Application in Agriculture: Research in China explored the use of PVA in agricultural applications, such as seed coatings and controlled-release fertilizers. The study found that PVA-based materials decomposed effectively in soil, enhancing plant growth without leaving harmful residues. This highlights PVA's potential for eco-friendly agricultural practices​ (lowcarbonbuildings.org)​.
        4. Marine Biodegradability Study: A study published in Marine Pollution Bulletin examined the degradation of PVA in marine environments. The research indicated that while PVA is biodegradable, the rate of degradation can vary significantly depending on the specific marine conditions, such as temperature and microbial activity. This suggests that PVA's impact on marine ecosystems is relatively low compared to conventional plastics​ (fominsoap)​.
        5. Biodegradation Study in South Korea: South Korean researchers investigated the biodegradation of PVA in wastewater treatment plants. The study concluded that PVA undergoes significant degradation during the wastewater treatment process, with microorganisms playing a crucial role. This supports the use of PVA in products that are likely to end up in wastewater, such as laundry and dishwasher pods​ (lowcarbonbuildings.org)​​ (fominsoap)​.

          These studies collectively demonstrate that PVA is generally safe for the environment when used and disposed of properly. Its biodegradability and non-toxic nature make it a viable alternative to traditional plastics in various applications, from packaging to medical devices. However, the rate and extent of biodegradation can vary depending on environmental conditions, which is an important consideration for its use and disposal.

          Conclusion

          Based on extensive research and decades of use, we confidently assert that PVA is safe for the environment. It is biodegradable, non-toxic, and does not contribute to microplastic pollution. At ReShine Earth, we are committed to using materials that align with our values of sustainability and safety. We encourage our customers to stay informed and trust in the extensive scientific evidence supporting PVA’s eco-friendliness.

          For further reading, you can explore detailed fact sheets from reputable sources like the American Cleaning Institute and comprehensive environmental assessments available online​ (epa)​​ (vove)​.

          Thank you for choosing ReShine Earth and supporting our commitment to a sustainable future.

          Citations:

          1. DeMerlis, C.C., & Schoneker, D.R. (2003). Review of the oral toxicity of polyvinyl alcohol (PVA). Food and Chemical Toxicology, 41(3), 319-326.
          2. Byrne, D., Boeije, G., Croft, I., Hüttmann, G., Luijkx, G., Meier, F., Parulekar, Y., & Stijntjes, G. (2021). Biodegradability of Polyvinyl Alcohol Based Film Used for Liquid Detergent Capsules. Tenside Surfactants Detergents, 58(2), 88-96.
          3. Salehpour, S., Jonoobi, M., Ahmadzadeh, M., Siracusa, V., Rafieian, F., & Oksman, K. (2018). Biodegradation and ecotoxicological impact of cellulose nanocomposites in municipal solid waste composting. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules, 111, 264-270.
          4. Chiellini, E., Corti, A., D'Antone, S., & Solaro, R. (2003). Biodegradation of poly(vinyl alcohol) based materials. Progress in Polymer Science, 28(6), 963-1014.
          5. Rolsky, C., & Kelkar, V. (2021). Degradation of Polyvinyl Alcohol in US Wastewater Treatment Plants and Subsequent Nationwide Emission Estimate. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18(11), 6027.
          6. Freedhoff, M. (2023). Letter to Paiji Yoo, S., & Cohen, D. April 21, 2023.
          7. Freedhoff, M. (2023). Pre-publication notice. April 21, 2023.
          8. Demystifying PVA: A look at its Environmental Impact.
          Back to blog